If you’ve been accused or charged with murder in Akron or anywhere in Ohio, hope is not lost. Our attorneys at Hiltner Trial Lawyers have successfully defended people charged with murder and brought them home to their families with all charges dropped.
Defending Murder Cases in Ohio
Murder charges in Ohio are the most serious types of criminal charges someone can face. That’s because murder, unlike manslaughter, suggests that the perpetrator had the intent to kill their victim.
Ohio law states that a person accused of murder must be suspected of all of the following:
- Purposefully causing the death a person other than himself (or unlawful termination of a pregnancy)
- Causing the death of another person while attempting to commit a violent felony (with some exceptions)
If convicted of murder, you could face the harshest penalties permissible by law, ranging anywhere from 15-30 years in prison, a life sentence, or even the death penalty. Serious fines may be included in the penalty, as well as a class 2 suspension of the perpetrator’s driver’s license if a motor vehicle was involved when they allegedly committed the crime.
Murder vs. Aggravated Murder in Ohio: what’s the difference?
Ohio separates homicide offenses into different categories, and the charging decision usually depends on intent, surrounding circumstances, and specific allegations.
Aggravated Murder (ORC 2903.01)
Aggravated murder generally involves allegations of purposeful killing with additional factors that make the charge more serious (such as certain specified circumstances under Ohio law).
Murder (ORC 2903.02)
Murder often involves allegations that a person purposely caused the death of another, or a death resulted as a proximate result of committing or attempting to commit certain serious offenses (“felony murder”).
Manslaughter and other lesser-included offenses
Depending on the facts, a homicide accusation may be charged—or negotiated—into a different category, including various forms of manslaughter or assault-related offenses.
Penalties for murder and aggravated murder in Ohio
Sentencing in an Ohio homicide case is severe and depends on the exact charge, specifications, and the facts presented.
- Murder penalties in Ohio: A conviction for murder in Ohio is typically punishable by an indefinite prison term of 15 years to life.
- Aggravated Murder penalties in Ohio: Aggravated murder sentencing can involve life sentences and, in certain cases involving aggravating circumstances/specifications, the sentencing process follows Ohio’s statutory framework for aggravated murder.
Because the stakes are so high, the defense approach in homicide cases often focuses on:
-
challenging the legality of the stop/arrest/search
-
testing the state’s forensic and medical conclusions
-
identifying alternative explanations and timelines
-
attacking witness credibility and motive
-
litigating self-defense or defense of others where supported
Where murder and homicide cases are handled in Akron and Summit County
Most murder and aggravated murder cases in Summit County end up in the Summit County Court of Common Pleas (General Division), which is the trial-level court that handles felony criminal cases.
However, it’s common for the earliest stages to start in a municipal court—especially if the case begins with a complaint and arrest before an indictment is returned. In Akron-area cases, the Akron Municipal Court may handle initial felony proceedings (like bond and early hearings) before the matter is bound over to Common Pleas.
Why this matters: the first days are often when key decisions are made—bond conditions, no-contact orders, witness issues, and evidence preservation. Early representation can help protect your rights and prevent mistakes that can follow you throughout the case.
Max Hiltner known for fighting tooth and nail for his clients — especially in high-stakes cases like murder and homicide defense. When your freedom and future are on the line, you need a lawyer who prepares relentlessly, challenges every piece of evidence, and is ready to take your case to trial.
Self-Defense Cases in Ohio
In some instances, it may be necessary to protect yourself or others.
Traditionally, Ohio has always had the “Castle Doctrine,” which means that a person does not have a duty to try to run away (or voice their intent to run away) before using self-defense if they are defending themselves in their home, place of business, or their car.
As of April 6, 2021, Ohio’s new “Stand Your Ground” law ORC 2901.09 has also gone into effect.
The new law states that the duty to run away (known as a “duty to retreat”) no longer applies to any cases of self-defense.
But this does not mean that claiming self-defense is necessarily easier.
- They were not the aggressor in the situation; and
- They had a reasonable belief that they were in danger
What to do if you or a loved one is facing a murder investigation or charge in Akron
If law enforcement has contacted you—or someone close to you has been arrested—what happens in the first days can shape the entire case.
Here are the most important next steps:
-
Do not give statements to police or detectives without counsel present—no “quick chat,” no “clearing things up.”
-
Do not contact witnesses or alleged victims’ family members. Even well-intended contact can create new allegations.
-
Preserve evidence immediately: texts, call logs, social media messages, location data, photos, surveillance footage, receipts, and names of potential witnesses.
-
Write down a timeline while events are fresh—who, what, when, where (but keep it private and share it only with your attorney).
-
Avoid posting online about the incident or your whereabouts. Prosecutors routinely use social media.
-
Get counsel involved early to address bond, no-contact orders, device searches, and evidence preservation—before the state’s theory hardens.
If you need help, the safest move is to speak with a defense attorney as soon as possible.
Why Choose Hiltner Trial Lawyers
Understandably, you need an experienced and dedicated defense attorney to defend you if you’re charged with murder in Ohio. At Hiltner Trial Lawyers, we’ve helped many clients through their murder cases.
At Hiltner Trial Lawyers, we’ve helped many clients through their murder cases.
One of our most high-profile cases involved a young woman who had acted in self-defense and was accused of murder. The jury trial lasted approximately two weeks and resulted in a hung jury, and the young woman was able to go home.
View more results
FAQs About Murder Charges in Ohio
This section answers common questions about murder charges in Ohio, including what the law requires, how murder differs from manslaughter, what penalties may apply, and when self-defense can be raised. If you’re being investigated or charged in Akron or anywhere in Northeast Ohio, Hiltner Trial Lawyers can help you understand the process and take steps to protect your future.
What is considered murder under Ohio law?
In Ohio, “murder” generally means a person purposely causes the death of another person. Ohio also recognizes a form of felony murder, where someone can be charged if a death happens as a proximate result of committing or attempting certain serious felonies (typically first- or second-degree felony “offenses of violence”).
How is murder different from manslaughter or other homicide charges?
“Homicide” is the umbrella category—it can include murder, manslaughter, and other unlawful killings.
The biggest difference usually comes down to state of mind (intent):
-
Murder typically involves acting purposely (or involves felony-murder rules).
-
Voluntary manslaughter often involves a killing that happens in a “sudden passion” or “fit of rage” caused by serious provocation.
-
Involuntary manslaughter usually involves a death that occurs while committing certain crimes or reckless conduct (the facts matter a lot).
An attorney can explain the difference between murder vs. manslaughter in Ohio based on the evidence, statements, and forensic issues.
What happens during a consultation with an Ohio murder defense lawyer?
Most consultations are focused on protecting you early and preventing avoidable damage to your case. A defense lawyer will usually:
-
Hear what happened from your perspective
-
Identify what you’re being accused of (or what police think happened)
-
Explain your rights and what not to do next
-
Walk through possible defenses and the likely path of the case (investigation vs. formal charges)
And yes—your conversation with your attorney is confidential.
What penalties can someone face if convicted of murder in Ohio?
Murder is one of the most serious charges in Ohio. In many cases, the penalty involves life imprisonment with parole eligibility after a minimum term, depending on the situation and sentencing structure. Ohio’s murder penalty is governed by the sentencing statute tied to the murder law.
Because sentencing details can change based on facts (and because related charges may apply), it’s smart to have a lawyer review the specific allegations before assuming a “one-size-fits-all” number.
Can self-defense be used as a defense in a murder case in Ohio?
Yes—self-defense can be a defense to a murder charge in Ohio, but these cases are extremely fact-sensitive.
One important point many people don’t realize: Ohio law places the burden on the prosecution to disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt once self-defense is properly raised.
Whether the force was “reasonable” depends on details like the threat level, the timeline, witness accounts, physical evidence, and prior history.
What should I do if I’m being investigated for murder but not yet charged?
If police contact you—or you suspect you’re under investigation—talk to a defense attorney before giving statements. Even “trying to clear it up” can backfire, especially when investigators already have a theory.
Early legal help can:
-
Reduce the risk of damaging statements
-
Preserve evidence and identify witnesses
-
Push back on inaccurate narratives before charges are filed
Can murder charges be reduced or dismissed?
Sometimes, yes. Depending on the evidence, murder charges may be reduced or dismissed due to issues like:
-
Weak or inconsistent evidence
-
Problems with how evidence was collected (constitutional violations)
-
A credible self-defense theory
-
Forensic or witness reliability issues
A defense strategy is built case-by-case—there’s no universal script.
Why is it important to hire an experienced Ohio murder defense attorney?
Murder cases move fast and carry high stakes. A seasoned defense lawyer understands how to challenge:
-
Forensic conclusions and timelines
-
Witness credibility and inconsistencies
-
Digital evidence and surveillance gaps
-
Police procedure and constitutional issues
-
Overcharging (when facts fit a different offense)
When your freedom is on the line, you want someone who has handled serious felony cases and knows how Ohio prosecutors build these prosecutions.
Press
Featured on:
Press
Featured on:
Contact Ohio attorney Max Hiltner to secure your defense today
If you or someone you love has been accused or charged with murder, this is probably one of the scariest days of your life. And you’re going to need a good defense attorney in your corner. Contact Hiltner Trial Lawyers to discuss your case in your first consultation.
Call 330-475-3164 for a free consultation
“Max Hiltner is dynamite in the courtroom by connecting with the jury, recalling facts and cultivating good relationships with the opponents and presiding judge. He is professional, dedicated, honest and cares about the livelihood of his clients and their families. He excels in negotiating and hiring experts necessary for a well rounded defense. Max was one of my lawyers that stood between me and a life sentence. Without him on my team I would still be in prison. He will fight for you.”
- Colleen O.
Send a message
I was supporting a friend going through a really rough time with the law. The prosecutor was relentless and it seemed every angle we approached got shot down. With research we found Max. When we sat down and talked to Max and Andrew, not only were they professional, they were empathetic and compassionate. They are genuine in their work and in their words. These are guys that you want in your corner, they fight against all odds, they Pioneer new avenues To fight for you, they stay up-to-date on recent cases that may apply to your current case. While going through the legal battle, they also used informative information, keeping my friend in the loop every step of the way. Explaining legal terms, taking the time to lay out the picture. I am writing this review to give credit to this team of lawyers, Being a veteran, there are a few people I’d trust to have my back in combat, but if it was a legal battle These are the guys I want to have my back. They work timely, efficiently, and professionally to secure the best outcome possible. They demonstrated that clients aren’t just a paycheck. They authentically care about each individual person they work with, Understanding the person‘s background, the family they have, They label the importance of the individual they’re representing as if it were themselves. I gave them five stars because they do their homework, They’re personable, Genuinely care about the individual, They work relentlessly, And their work is outstanding.
I’m so glad i chose max to represent me. The best lawyer hands down. Went above and beyond my expectations and can’t thank him enough. I highly recommend him to anyone in need!
Max was so helpful through the entire process. He clearly answered all of my questions and provided a straightforward response of what to expect. Max's services were unmatched and he got me a satisfactory result faster than what I expected. I would recommend him to anyone who needs assistance with a case.
Max and his team provide exceptional support and service. They are true experts in their field and consistently go above and beyond to ensure the best possible outcome, no matter the circumstances. Their dedication and commitment to their clients set them apart, and I couldn’t be more grateful for their help and guidance.
We as a family highly recommend Max Hiltner. He is dependable and constantly communicative. He is excellent at addressing questions and explaining the gravity of situations and legal details in a clear and understandable way. He makes himself accessible when issues arise and goes above and beyond for his clients.
First time having to use a lawyer, and I was glad that I chose Hiltner. If you want results, he is the man. He fought for me, gave me solid advice, and showed empathy for me during my crisis. He was understanding of my financial situation and gave me time to make my payments. He even provided additional services to help me on other matters that came up not discussed on our contract, which I truthly appreciate. If you want a lawyer that will fight for you with everything that he's got and to treat you with respect, look no further.
We’re do I start as buiness owner I was stress out with the legal system so I called max. Once I talk to him about my situation . He took my case and I can tell you he is the best lawyer and. Cares about his clients all the way. Don’t mess around and waste money on small town lawyers . Got to max and he will get it done to the best he can !!!!! Amazing experience I found my forever lawyer!!!!!! Great amazing job max my family and I appreciate everything you do !!!
I am grateful for the outstanding legal representation I received from Max Hiltner. He not only possesses a deep understanding of the law but also goes above and beyond to prioritize clients' needs. Max guided me with clarity and transparency, making a complex legal situation more manageable. The communication was prompt, and his dedication to my case was evident throughout. I highly recommend Max for anyone seeking a knowledgeable and reliable attorney. Thank you for your exceptional service!
I worked with Max, and he listened to my concerns and desired outcomes, and got me to where I wanted to be. He also explained options at each step and guided me along our legal path to resolution. I trusted him to work for my interests, and he absolutely did.
I reached out to several lawyers for help. Most sent automated emails back with lists of fees for various services.
Max is the only one who called me personally to ask how he can help.
After hiring Max, he patiently listened to everything I had to say and answered all of my questions.
He helped me get an amazing deal during a very difficult situation.
10/10
Max is the only one who called me personally to ask how he can help.
After hiring Max, he patiently listened to everything I had to say and answered all of my questions.
He helped me get an amazing deal during a very difficult situation.
10/10
Max was the first lawyer we spoke with who we felt actually heard our side of the story. From the first phone call he asked specific questions and was available. Max worked hard to get us the best possible outcome and took time to make sure we knew the legal processes at work. This is the guy you want on your side.
