Being accused of theft — particularly in Ohio — is no small matter. Penalties for felony theft can vary, but even fifth-degree felony theft can require steep fines and serious jail time.
If you’ve been accused or charged with felony theft in Ohio, hope is not lost. Our attorneys at Hiltner Trial Lawyers have successfully defended people charged with felony theft and brought them home to their families with all charges dropped.
At Hiltner Trial Lawyers, we have a reputation for fighting to keep good people out of prison. Lead attorney Max Hiltner is known for his reputation as a trial lawyer who fights tooth and nail for his clients each and every time. He’s often hired by other attorneys to try cases on their behalf, and he’s been honored to frequently speak at CLEs around the country.
Hiltner recently sought to set a new personal record: three not guilty verdicts in three days. However, he was never given the opportunity. Due to his extensive investigation and trial preparation for each of his three clients in three different cases, all charges were dismissed prior to trial. In fact, the day before each client’s jury trial the State dismissed all charges against all clients.
At Hiltner Trial Lawyers, we have a reputation for fighting to keep good people out of prison. Lead attorney Max Hiltner is known for his reputation as a trial lawyer who fights tooth and nail for his clients each and every time. He’s often hired by other attorneys to try cases on their behalf, and he’s been honored to frequently speak at CLEs around the country.
Hiltner recently sought to set a new personal record: three not guilty verdicts in three days. However, he was never given the opportunity. Due to his extensive investigation and trial preparation for each of his three clients in three different cases, all charges were dismissed prior to trial. In fact, the day before each client’s jury trial the State dismissed all charges against all clients.
Under Ohio law, theft becomes a felony when the value of the property or services involved exceeds certain thresholds or when the theft involves protected property or victims. Felony theft charges are governed by Ohio Revised Code § 2913.02.
The difference is primarily based on value and circumstances. Misdemeanor theft typically involves lower-value property, while felony theft applies to higher-value losses or specific types of property, such as firearms or motor vehicles.
Felony theft penalties may include prison time, fines, restitution to the alleged victim, probation, and a permanent felony record. The severity of punishment depends on the degree of the felony and prior criminal history.
During a confidential consultation, the attorney will review the allegations, explain the potential charges and penalties, assess the evidence, and discuss possible defense strategies. Early legal involvement is critical in theft cases.
Yes. Charges may be reduced or dismissed if the prosecution cannot prove intent, ownership, or value, or if constitutional violations occurred during the investigation or arrest.
Yes. Ohio law requires proof that the accused knowingly intended to deprive the owner of property or services. Lack of intent can be a key defense.
No. You should not speak with law enforcement without an attorney present. Statements made during an investigation can be used against you later.
A defense attorney can challenge valuation, intent, and ownership claims, negotiate with prosecutors, and work to reduce charges, limit penalties, or seek dismissal.
© 2026 Hiltner Trial Lawyers. | 
